If you are holding a crib mattress right now

Maybe it is your own, from the first baby, and it has been in a closet for three years. Maybe a friend is offering one. Either way, these four checks settle it, and any one of them can end the decision.

  1. Find the date. Every mattress sold in the US must carry a permanent label with its month and year of manufacture, usually on the white tag sewn into a seam. Regulatory — 16 CFR 1632.31 A missing or cut-off tag means you do not know how old it is. Treat that as a reason to pass.
  2. Read that date against two others. Made before August 15, 2022, it was never required to pass a firmness test, so step 3 carries more weight. Made before February 10, 2009, it predates the federal limit on phthalates in crib mattresses. We would not put a baby on a mattress that old.
  3. Do the firmness test. Two milk cartons and a stack of CDs, set on the softest spot. If the overhang touches the mattress, it is too soft. The method is below.
  4. Check the cover and the fit. Look for cracks, splits or tears in the waterproof cover, and for stains or a musty smell that reach the foam. In the crib, if you can fit more than two fingers between the mattress and the frame, the American Academy of Pediatrics says the combination "should not be used." Regulatory — AAP, HealthyChildren.org

If it passes all four, its age alone is not a reason to throw it out. If it fails one, retire it, whatever the label says.

No expiry date, but a date on the label

We read the federal crib mattress standard looking for a lifespan. It sets rules for size, fit, firmness, coil springs and warning labels, and it says nothing about how many years a crib mattress may be used. Regulatory — 16 CFR Part 1241

What the law does require is a date. The mattress flammability rule, which names crib mattresses in its definition of a mattress, requires "a permanent, accessible, and legible label containing the month and year of manufacture." Regulatory — 16 CFR 1632.31 Since 2022, crib mattresses have also been on the federal list of durable infant products, which must be permanently marked with the model and date of manufacture and come with a registration card so the maker can reach you about a recall. Regulatory — 16 CFR Part 1130

So where do the lifespans you see quoted come from? From the makers. We read the websites of 18 crib mattress makers on November 14, 2026, and several of them blocked us. These are the pages that state a number or take a position, copied word for word:

MakerWhat its own site says
Newton Baby"a crib mattress should be replaced every five years" (one post). "Generally, your crib mattress should last five to seven years" (a second). "a mattress typically lasts only five to six years" (a third).
Moonlight Slumber"The product lifetime for Moonlight mattresses is 8 years." On its warranty page: "The expected lifetime of a crib mattress is 5-8 years depending on use, care and conditions."
AvocadoOne help article mentions "a crib mattress, which is replaced at 18 months". Another says "We are not publishing a service-life figure for our mattresses until our updated third-party lifecycle assessment is complete."
Naturepedic"Crib mattresses don't have a strict expiration date, but they should be replaced when they show signs of wear"
Lullaby Earth"Most crib mattresses can be used throughout one child's crib years", and often for later children if they are still in good condition.

Industry — maker websites, read November 14, 2026

The makers that publish a crib mattress lifespan put it at 5 to 8 years, and none of the pages we read cites a test, a study or a standard for that number. Industry Newton gives three different figures on three pages of its own site. Every company in this table sells crib mattresses. The adult version of this question has the same gap, and we traced where its seven-year rule comes from in how long mattresses really last.

The warranties say more than the lifespans do, because the long ones end when the mattress changes hands. Newton's excludes "items bought as used or secondhand products," and Babyletto's uses the same words. Kolcraft says products bought "second-hand do not qualify for the warranty." Moonlight's applies "only to the original purchaser," and Halo's "only to the original retail purchaser." Industry — maker warranty pages A crib mattress can carry a lifetime warranty and have no warranty at all the day a friend hands it to you.

The two dates that change what you are holding

The label date matters because two federal rules changed what a crib mattress had to be. A mattress made before either one was built to an older standard, however good it looks.

August 15, 2022: the first US firmness test

Before 2022 the US crib mattress standard was voluntary, written by the industry standards body ASTM, and it had no firmness test. When the Consumer Product Safety Commission made the standard mandatory, it noted that the Australian, New Zealand and European standards each included one, "while the ASTM standard does not," and added a test based on the Australian method. Regulatory — 87 FR 8640 The rule took effect on August 15, 2022.

The test itself is plain to describe. A rigid disc weighing 5,200 g sits on the mattress with a thin bar sticking out 40 mm past its edge, 15 mm above the bottom. To pass, "the feeler arm shall not contact the sleep surface of the crib mattress." Regulatory — 87 FR 8640, sections 5.10 and 6.3 In 2026 the commission adopted an updated industry standard that now carries the firmness test itself. Regulatory — 91 FR 6510

So a crib mattress made before August 2022 was never required to pass a firmness test in the US. Plenty of them are firm. No rule made anyone check. Inferred And new does not guarantee firm either: when Chicago pediatric researchers measured household sleep surfaces in 2019 and 2020, Gillani et al. (2021) found "some infant mattresses as soft as some adult mattresses." Peer-reviewed — Gillani 2021

February 10, 2009: the phthalate limit

Phthalates are plasticizers, the additives that make vinyl soft. From February 10, 2009, products a child 3 and younger uses for sleeping could not contain more than 0.1% of six of them, "regardless of when they were manufactured," and the commission gave a crib mattress as its example of such a product. Regulatory — CPSC release 09-121 The limit today covers eight phthalates, in any plasticized part. Regulatory — 16 CFR Part 1307

Crib mattress covers were heavily plasticized. Boor et al. (2015) analyzed 20 new and used crib mattresses: 17 of the 20 covers held at least one identifiable plasticizer, 9 held DEHP or DINP, and in mattresses made after the 2009 law, replacement plasticizers such as DINCH were the ones found most often. Peer-reviewed — Boor 2015

Mattress age shows up in a child's bedroom air. Vaezafshar et al. (2025) put passive air samplers in 25 bedrooms of children aged 6 months to 4 years in Toronto and Ottawa and reported that "Older mattresses had higher concentrations of di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate (DEHP) and benzyl butyl phthalate (BzBP)." Peer-reviewed — Vaezafshar 2025

BzBP is another name for BBP, and both it and DEHP are on the federal list capped in crib mattresses since 2009. Both are also already in nearly everyone. In Canada's national biomonitoring survey for 2018–2019, a DEHP breakdown product turned up in 100% of people tested and a BBP breakdown product in 98.3%. Regulatory — Canadian Health Measures Survey, via the Exposure Ledger Those numbers say nothing about where the phthalate came from. They do say an old crib mattress adds to an exposure almost everyone already carries. Inferred

This part cuts against what we have written before. The usual case for an older mattress is that it has finished off-gassing, and for the light, fast-evaporating compounds that holds: Boor et al. (2014) measured lower emissions from used crib mattresses than from new ones. Peer-reviewed — Boor 2014 But a mattress is also made under the rules of its year. For the plasticizers in its cover, age tells you which formula you got. It says much less about how far the mattress has aired out.

What actually wears out

The foam gets softer

Foam loses firmness as it ages. In a lab weathering study of three mattress foams, Scarfato et al. (2017) found that all of them lost "surface firmness and resistance to bottoming out" as they aged. Peer-reviewed — Scarfato 2017 That study aged foam samples with heat and moisture in a chamber, not crib mattresses over years of use, so it shows the direction and not the timeline. A crib mattress that passed the firmness test new can fail it later, which is why the test decides and the label date only tells you how hard to look.

The cover cracks

The waterproof cover keeps urine, milk and spit-up out of the foam, and it is the other part with a working life. The best clue that it matters comes from the research behind the used-mattress warning itself. When Brooke et al. (1997) first linked SIDS to mattresses previously used by another infant or adult, they added that the "increased risk was not established for mattresses totally covered by polyvinyl chloride." Peer-reviewed — Brooke 1997 Later lab work by Sherburn and Jenkins (2004) found significantly higher bacterial counts in cot mattress foam left exposed than in foam completely covered by vinyl. Peer-reviewed — Sherburn 2004

Neither study shows why the risk appeared. Both point at the same part: a cover that seals keeps the foam clean, and once it splits, the foam underneath cannot be cleaned again. Inferred There is an awkward overlap here, and we do not have a way around it. The fully sealed vinyl cover that kept the foam clean in those studies is the same layer plasticizers are added to, which is one more reason the date on the label matters.

The five-minute firmness test

Ron Somers, one of the researchers behind the Australian firmness test the US rule is based on, designed a version you can do with things from a kitchen. Peer-reviewed — Somers 2012 This is the method as the Australian consumer group CHOICE publishes it. Industry — CHOICE

  1. Get two unopened 1-liter milk or juice cartons with square bottoms, and a stack of 12 CDs or DVDs wrapped tightly in cling film.
  2. Draw a line all the way around one carton, 40 mm up from its base.
  3. Put the disc stack on the softest part of the mattress, or anywhere a baby's face could end up, such as a dip or a seam.
  4. Lay the marked carton on its side on the discs, with the line at the edge of the stack, so 40 mm hangs over the mattress. Stack the second carton on top of the first, as level as you can.
  5. Look at the overhang. If it touches the mattress, the mattress is too soft. Repeat in a few spots, especially where the head goes.

CHOICE is plain that this is a home check and not a replacement for the lab test, and also that "If your mattress fails this test then it is definitely not safe." Industry — CHOICE The 40 mm overhang matches the federal test. The weight does not: two liters of milk come to about 2 kg, against the federal disc's 5.2 kg. So a pass at home is not a federal pass. A mattress that fails under the lighter load would almost certainly fail under the heavier one. Inferred — our comparison with 87 FR 8640

Your own mattress, for a second baby

Reusing your own crib mattress is the easy case, and the Scottish study that raised the alarm is why. Tappin et al. (2002) found the association with SIDS "significantly stronger if the mattress was from another home (4.78, 2.08 to 11.0) than if it was from the same home (1.64, 0.64 to 4.2)." Peer-reviewed — Tappin 2002 For a mattress from the same home, that range runs from below 1 to above 4, so the study could not tell it apart from no effect at all. The authors also wrote that "Insufficient evidence is available to judge whether this relation is cause and effect." Peer-reviewed — Tappin 2002

Newton, which says of hand-me-downs from other families that "we strongly recommend against it," also says that for a mattress you bought new, kept clean and stored dry, "it would be acceptable to use the same mattress for your second (or third, etc.) child." Industry — Newton Baby Its own help page, a little oddly, calls its mattress "a hand-me-down you can feel good about." If yours passes the four checks at the top of this page, we agree. A mattress from someone else's home is the harder question, and our piece on secondhand crib mattresses works through it.

What we got wrong

Two things in our secondhand crib mattress article did not survive the reading for this one. Both are corrected there as of November 14, 2026.

It said that a used mattress "isn't adding chemistry; it's a few years further along the same decay curve than a new one." That holds for the fast-evaporating compounds. It does not hold for the plasticizers in the cover. A mattress made before 2009 may have been made with phthalates the law now caps, and the Toronto and Ottawa bedrooms above had more of two of them around older mattresses.

It also said the Scottish used-mattress finding "has never been cleanly replicated" and that "other analyses have not found the effect to hold up." We went looking for those other analyses and did not find one. What we found is that the 2002 study was itself the follow-up. The same group saw the signal in 1997, wrote that it "needs confirmation before recommendations can be made," and found it again in a new set of cases. Peer-reviewed — Brooke 1997; Tappin 2002 That is still one research group in one country, and we have not found a study elsewhere that tested it. The line about it failing to hold up was ours, and we could not support it.

What this does not establish

It does not give you a safe age. We found no study that followed crib mattresses over years in real cribs and recorded when they stopped passing a firmness test. The 5-to-8-year figures are makers' estimates, and they give no basis for them.

The phthalate finding is about air, not health. Vaezafshar et al. measured what was in the air near mattresses in 25 bedrooms in two Canadian cities. That shows exposure. It does not show harm to any child, and 25 bedrooms is a small sample.

The used-mattress SIDS signal is still unsettled. It is an association from case-control studies by one group, and its authors were the first to say it does not prove cause. The firmness, back-sleeping and bare-crib rules apply to every mattress, new or old, and they matter more.

The kitchen test is not the federal test. It is lighter and less exact. It can tell you a mattress is too soft. It cannot certify one as firm enough.

Frequently asked questions

Do crib mattresses expire?

No. No US rule sets an expiry date or a lifespan for a crib mattress. Federal rules do require a permanent label showing the month and year it was made. Replace a crib mattress when it fails a firmness test, when its waterproof cover is cracked or torn, or when it no longer fits the crib snugly, whatever its age.

How long does a crib mattress last?

The makers that publish a figure put it at 5 to 8 years. Newton Baby says five to seven years on one page and five on another, and Moonlight Slumber says 5 to 8. None of the pages we read cites a test for the number. In practice a crib mattress lasts as long as it stays firm, its cover stays intact and it still fits the crib.

Can you reuse a crib mattress for a second baby?

Usually, yes, if it is your own, it was stored clean and dry, and it still passes the firmness, cover and fit checks. In the Scottish study behind the used-mattress warning, the link with SIDS was much weaker for a mattress from the same home than for one from another home, and for the same-home case it was not statistically significant.

Are older crib mattresses made with different chemicals?

Some are. Since February 10, 2009, US law has limited restricted phthalates in crib mattresses to 0.1%. A 2015 study of 20 crib mattresses found replacement plasticizers were the most common ones in mattresses made after that law, and a 2025 study in 25 Canadian bedrooms found older mattresses gave off more DEHP and BBP.

How do I know if a crib mattress is too soft?

Use the home firmness test. Wrap 12 CDs in cling film and set them on the softest spot. Lay an unopened 1-liter milk carton on its side on the stack with 40 mm hanging over the edge, and stack a second carton on top. If the overhang touches the mattress, it is too soft. Crib mattresses made since August 15, 2022 must also pass a federal firmness test.

Where is the manufacture date on a crib mattress?

On a permanent label, usually the white tag sewn into a seam. Federal flammability rules require every mattress, crib mattresses included, to show its month and year of manufacture. If the tag is missing or cut off, you do not know how old the mattress is.

References

  1. Boor BE, Liang Y, Crain NE, Järnström H, Novoselac A, Xu Y (2015). "Identification of Phthalate and Alternative Plasticizers, Flame Retardants, and Unreacted Isocyanates in Infant Crib Mattress Covers and Foam." Environmental Science & Technology Letters 2(4): 89–94. DOI 10.1021/acs.estlett.5b00039 Peer-reviewed
  2. Vaezafshar S, Wolk S, Arrandale VH, Sühring R, Phipps E, Jantunen LM, Diamond ML (2025). "Young Children's Exposure to Chemicals of Concern in Their Sleeping Environment: An In-Home Study." Environmental Science & Technology Letters 12(5): 468–475. DOI 10.1021/acs.estlett.5c00051 Peer-reviewed
  3. Boor BE, Järnström H, Novoselac A, Xu Y (2014). "Infant Exposure to Emissions of Volatile Organic Compounds from Crib Mattresses." Environmental Science & Technology 48(6): 3541–3549. DOI 10.1021/es405625q Peer-reviewed
  4. Gillani SH, Lowell GS, Quinlan KP (2021). "A firm recommendation: measuring the softness of infant sleep surfaces." Injury Epidemiology 8(Suppl 1): 30. DOI 10.1186/s40621-021-00325-x Peer-reviewed
  5. Scarfato P, Di Maio L, Incarnato L (2017). "Structure and physical-mechanical properties related to comfort of flexible polyurethane foams for mattress and effects of artificial weathering." Composites Part B: Engineering 109: 45–52. DOI 10.1016/j.compositesb.2016.10.041 Peer-reviewed
  6. Brooke H, Gibson A, Tappin D, Brown H (1997). "Case-control study of sudden infant death syndrome in Scotland, 1992-5." BMJ 314(7093): 1516–1520. DOI 10.1136/bmj.314.7093.1516 Peer-reviewed
  7. Tappin D, Brooke H, Ecob R, Gibson A (2002). "Used infant mattresses and sudden infant death syndrome in Scotland: case-control study." BMJ 325(7371): 1007. DOI 10.1136/bmj.325.7371.1007 Peer-reviewed
  8. Sherburn RE, Jenkins RO (2004). "Cot mattresses as reservoirs of potentially harmful bacteria and the sudden infant death syndrome." FEMS Immunology and Medical Microbiology 42(1): 76–84. DOI 10.1016/j.femsim.2004.06.011 Peer-reviewed
  9. Somers RL (2012). "Assessment of infant mattress firmness: a do-it-yourself safety test to reduce the risk of asphyxiation." Australian and New Zealand Journal of Public Health 36(5): 490–491. DOI 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2012.00920.x Peer-reviewed
  10. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 16 CFR Part 1241, Safety Standard for Crib Mattresses. ecfr.gov Regulatory
  11. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. "Safety Standard for Crib Mattresses," final rule, 87 FR 8640 (February 15, 2022), effective August 15, 2022. federalregister.gov Regulatory
  12. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. "Safety Standard for Crib Mattresses," direct final rule, 91 FR 6510 (February 12, 2026). federalregister.gov Regulatory
  13. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 16 CFR 1632.31, Mattresses/mattress pads: labeling, recordkeeping, guaranties. ecfr.gov Regulatory
  14. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 16 CFR Part 1130, Requirements for Consumer Registration of Durable Infant or Toddler Products. ecfr.gov Regulatory
  15. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. 16 CFR Part 1307, Prohibition of Children's Toys and Child Care Articles Containing Specified Phthalates. ecfr.gov Regulatory
  16. U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission. "CPSC Issues Guidance For Complying With Phthalates Requirements In New Child Safety Law," release 09-121, February 6, 2009. cpsc.gov Regulatory
  17. American Academy of Pediatrics. "Make Baby's Room Safe: Parent Checklist." HealthyChildren.org, last updated August 14, 2020. healthychildren.org Regulatory
  18. Statistics Canada and Health Canada. Canadian Health Measures Survey, human biomonitoring of environmental chemicals, as compiled in the Embr Exposure Ledger v1.5. open.canada.ca Regulatory
  19. CHOICE. "What to know before buying a cot mattress." choice.com.au Industry
  20. Newton Baby. "Crib mattress" (blog post) and "Crib mattress size" (blog post), read November 14, 2026. newtonbaby.com/blogs/nursery/crib-mattress; newtonbaby.com/blogs/news-tips/crib-mattress-size Industry
  21. Newton Baby. "Newton mattress and bassinet for less" and "Organic crib mattress" (blog posts), and Help page, read November 14, 2026. newtonbaby.com/blogs/hush/newton-mattress-bassinet-for-less; newtonbaby.com/blogs/hush/organic-crib-mattress; newtonbaby.com/pages/help Industry
  22. Moonlight Slumber. FAQ and Lifetime Warranty pages, read November 14, 2026. sleepmoonlight.com/pages/faq; sleepmoonlight.com/pages/lifetime-warranty Industry
  23. Avocado. Help center articles on mattress durability and on organic sleep for kids, read November 14, 2026. help.avocadogreenmattress.com (durability); help.avocadogreenmattress.com (kids) Industry
  24. Naturepedic. FAQs, "Do crib mattresses expire?", read November 14, 2026. naturepedic.com/pages/faqs Industry
  25. Lullaby Earth. "Are lightweight crib mattresses firm enough?" (blog post, January 21, 2026), read November 14, 2026. lullabyearth.com Industry
  26. Crib mattress warranty pages of Kolcraft, Babyletto and Halo, read November 14, 2026. kolcraft.com/warranty; babyletto.com/pages/warranty; halosleep.com/pages/halo-1-year-warranty Industry